What's with the Climate?

Voices of a Subcontinent grappling with Climate Change

Youth Protest Indo-US Nuclear Deal


Students on 8th Day of Hunger Strike“We’re on our 8th day of fasting,” said one of the students from Calicut University, Calicut, Kerela. “We don’t want nuclear to be a part of our future.” Several students including Abdul Rehman, Saji Mathew, Ramziya Rehmat, Tomy Jecob, Krupa and Divya, inspired by one of their professors came all the way from the southern state of Kerela up to the seat of power in Delhi to voice their concerns regarding the long-pending Indo-US nuclear power deal. They are members of the Students Against Nuclear Power (S.A.N.P) group.

The Indo-US Nuclear deal, also known as the “1, 2, 3” Deal has been full of controversy ever since its inception. Though first started by the NDA government of the late 90s and early 2000, it has reached its final stages under the current UPA-led coalition. The deal is significant for many reasons but mostly for its implications of India finally being deemed a “responsible nuclear power” status by the US–bringing the country out of official isolation on the subject. It is important to note that India has not signed the non-proliferation treaty.

The deal is being mooted crucial for India in terms of energy security as the nation currently imports 70% of its oil, which is expected to go up to 90% by mid-century if not sooner. India currently lacks supplies of uranium and the deal would allow technology sharing and the ability to buy uranium from the global market for the very first time. India’s plans are to utilize home grown technology, particularly the fast-breeder closedIndefinite Hunger Strike against Indo-US Nuclear Deal cycle process which involves enriching some thorium (of which conveniently India has some 30-odd percent of the global supply) with uranium to start the closed cycle. If India is to maintain its economic boom, it is expected that it will have to increase its energy production from the 125 gigawatts today to over 250 gigawatts by 2016. It is debatable however, how much of this will actually be achieved by boosting nuclear energy generation. Critics state that nuclear will still play a very small role in the over all energy mix.

Energy aside, controversy also exists around the fact that the agreement mightGandhi with spinning wheel on telephone asking about sovereignty with regards to energy security.  The wheel, a symbol of India’s independence itself is modified to look like the atomic symbol. compromise India’s sovereignty over the rights to its own weapons program which technically is a separate entity all together. Regardless, the question of the hour is should India push through the nuclear deal without much debate (as the current administrations plan on doing especially before President Bush is out of office), will it herald yet another missed opportunity for India to follow a more genuine path towards carbon-neutral growth? Can a population of 1.03 billion people with really high density accept any form of nuclear melt down like 3-mile island or the one that happened in Japan more recently? Furthermore is nuclear the way we solve our climate challenge?

Fasting students get a break from visit by author, Arundhati RoyFor the students, the purpose was clear: give the separate movements against nuclear from around the country a rallying point. I think they did just that. Many have come out in support. It was on the 8th day of fasting that I finally visited these brave youth. Leading leftist politicians arrived at the scene pleading them to stop the fast in assurance that they would carry forth the battle in parliament. ” Now that we have had our voices heard and helped unite the movement, we are going back and will carry on our struggle from Kerela,” stated the professor leading the students. I only hope that it is not too late.

Author: Kartikeya

Kartikeya Singh received his Master of Environmental Science degree at the School of Forestry & Environmental Studies at Yale University and a PhD in International Affairs from the Fletcher School of Law & Diplomacy. His research interests include climate change and energy policy and innovation.

5 thoughts on “Youth Protest Indo-US Nuclear Deal

  1. Solar power is totally clean and renewable and sustainable. I can’t understand why anyone would want to make a deal with the people who brought you Microsoft and the long tangle of unseen strings attached to it. These are not good people to do business with! They will have many hidden agendas, all of which will favor them! Go solar, go clean go renewable. At least the large initial cost is not hidden!

  2. I think there is no harm* in going Nuclear for the next 10 years or so, it would ensure positive economic growth and mainly reduce the GHG emmisions from conventional sources atleast for 10 years! chill guys lets be practical we cant be green overnight atleast by this way we can instantly reduce the GHG emmisions. we should be wise enough to use nuclear power till the date we can affort to go complete green….
    * ensure highest saftey measures – its possible!

  3. What do u think of this nuclear deal? Are u out of your mind? Who gets benefited due to this? We think u are sleeping in your office chair with out knowing what is happening. You spare the country for a votes?? I’m ashamed you are the prime minister of India. You are selling the country to others. You have taken a ridiculous decision. India doesn’t die without nuclear deal.

  4. Nuclear Energy or IAEA Agreement or deal is not going to solve the poverty issue. Indian politicians are confused what to do but to go by the USA thinking that they are more knowledge on the matters. Before the commitment on aggreement it has never been discussed. It is a sorry state of affairs when Government and prime minister make commitment without discussing about it in the Parliament. Now at this point of time MPs those are not sure of winning the coming election in the next term are coming forward to save the Government so as to make some money or deal with the present Governement.


  5. would like to know the credibility of these students. indefinite hunger strike?? incredulous. hope this deal comes through. some strings attached to it but there is no such thing as a free lunch. we are not giving away our sovereignty, people who say this need to have a sense of what the word actually means.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s